Against Absolute Goodness (Oxford Moral Theory) by Richard Kraut

By Richard Kraut

Are there issues we should always price simply because they're, with ease, solid? if that is so, such issues can be stated to have "absolute goodness." they might be solid simpliciter or complete cease - no longer sturdy for somebody, no longer sturdy of a type, yet still stable (period). they could even be known as "impersonal values." reasons why we should price such issues, if there are any, may simply be the truth that they're, easily, great things. within the 20th century, G. E. Moore used to be the good champion of absolute goodness, yet he's not the single thinker who posits the life and significance of this estate.

Against those pals of absolute goodness, Richard Kraut the following builds at the argument he made in What is sweet and Why, demonstrating that goodness isn't really a reason-giving estate - in reality, there's no such factor. it truly is, he holds, an insidious type of sensible inspiration, since it will be and has been used to justify what's damaging and condemn what's necessary. Impersonal worth attracts us clear of what's reliable for folks. His approach for opposing absolute goodness is to go looking for domain names of sensible reasoning within which it would be considered wanted, and this leads him to an exam of a wide selection of ethical phenomena: excitement, wisdom, attractiveness, love, cruelty, suicide, destiny generations, bio-diversity, killing in self-defense, and the extinction of our species. Even people, he proposes, shouldn't be stated to have absolute worth. The unique value of human existence rests in its place at the nice merits that such lives ordinarily provide.

"When one reads this, one sees the potential of genuine philosophical growth. If Kraut is true, I'd be fallacious to assert that this e-book is nice, interval. or perhaps nice, interval. yet i'm going to say that, as a piece of philosophy, and if you learn it, it truly is very good indeed." --Russ Shafer-Landau, college of Wisconsin-Madison

Show description

Read or Download Against Absolute Goodness (Oxford Moral Theory) PDF

Best social science books

Economic Concepts for the Social Sciences

This e-book provides an summary and evaluation of the conceptual advances in economics over the last century. The ebook is predicated seriously on attractive examples, meant to attract within the reader and to illustrate the far-reaching software of monetary reasoning to social phenomena. The publication is aimed toward a huge viewers together with people with very little formal education in economics.

Explaining Creativity: The Science of Human Innovation (2nd Edition)

Explaining Creativity is an obtainable advent to the most recent medical learn on creativity. The publication summarizes and integrates a huge diversity of analysis in psychology and comparable clinical fields. within the final forty years, psychologists, anthropologists, and sociologists have dedicated elevated recognition to creativity; we now understand extra approximately creativity than at any element in historical past.

Beyond Continuity: Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies

Wolfgang Streeck, Kathleen Thelen (eds. )

Debates surrounding institutional switch became more and more primary to Political technology, administration experiences, and Sociology, opposing the position of globalization in bringing a few convergence of nationwide economies and associations on one version to theories approximately 'Varieties of Capitalism'. This booklet brings jointly a exceptional set of members from a spread to envision present theories of institutional switch. The chapters spotlight the constraints of those theories, discovering them missing within the analytic instruments essential to establish the adjustments taking place at a countrywide point, and consequently are inclined to clarify many alterations and thoughts as easily one other model of past events. as a substitute a version emerges of up to date political economies constructing in incremental yet cumulatively transformative tactics. The individuals shoe large, yet now not limitless, number of versions of institutional switch exist that could meaningfully distinctive and analytically in comparison. they give an empirically grounded typology of modes of institutional switch that supply vital insights on mechanisms of social and political balance, and evolution ordinarily. past Continuity offers a extra complicated and primary knowing of institutional switch, and should be vital studying for lecturers, researchers, and complex scholars of Political technological know-how, administration reports, Sociology and Economics.

Erotic Capital: The Power of Attraction in the Boardroom and the Bedroom

In 2010, pioneering sociologist Catherine Hakim surprised the area with a provocative new thought: as well as the 3 famous own resources (economic, cultural, and social capital), every one person has a fourth asset—erotic capital—that she or he can, and may, use to boost inside society.

Extra info for Against Absolute Goodness (Oxford Moral Theory)

Example text

Normativity, p. 17. For discussion, see Charles R. Pigden, “Geach on Good,” Philosophical Quarterly 40 (1990), pp. 129–154; Michael J. Zimmerman, “In Defense of the Concept of Intrinsic Value,” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 29 (1999), pp. 389–400; Michael J. Zimmerman, The Nature of Intrinsic Value, pp. 15–32; and Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, “For Goodness’ Sake,” Southern Journal of Philosophy 41 (2003), Supplementary Volume: “The Legacy of G. E. Moore: 100 Years of Metaethics,” pp. 83–91. Thomson replies to Sinnott-Armstrong in that same issue, pp.

After all, if it has sometimes escaped the notice of some philosophers that they are failing to make sense, surely this can also happen to people who are (for good reason) less reflective about the concepts they are using. The failure to grasp the rules that govern the use of “good” may be quite widespread, just as logical fallacies are all too common. There is no doubt that in ordinary conversation people frequently use the word “good” without supplementing it with other phrases, because the context in which they speak makes it clear which further words are needed to make their meaning explicit.

So if we classify something as instrumentally advantageous, it must be effective, to some extent, in bringing about either what is noninstrumentally good for someone or preventing what is noninstrumentally bad for someone. Everyday practical discourse is filled with assertions about advantages and disadvantages. What we are committed to, when we use this discourse, is the assumption that some things are good for someone without their being good for someone as a means to a further end. If there is such a property as absolute goodness, then the things that are useful in producing whatever has that property can be called good.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.94 of 5 – based on 8 votes